🚩Tactical Memo 099: AI Exposes the First-Draft Employee

The draft takes 40 seconds now. What you put on top of it is the job.

Tactical Memo #099 | The Unwritten Rules · AI | 3 min read

Tactical Memo: one memo a week on career growth and modern management, read by 18,000+ leaders at Amazon, Deloitte, and Google. Forwarded? Subscribe free.

In brief

The situation: A tool now produces the first draft you used to spend a day on.

The mistake: Most people send drafts faster and call that the contribution.

The move: Put your recommendation in writing on top of every draft you send.

The story

Your boss asks for a summary of the 3 vendor proposals by Friday.

2 years ago, that was a full day of your week.

You read every proposal and built the comparison by hand.

Today a tool produces that document while you refill your coffee.

40 seconds. For what used to be a day.

You send it, and your boss says thanks.

Your boss could have typed that request without you.

So could anyone on your team.

If the draft was most of what you handed over each week, you're in this exact spot.

AI won't replace the employee who uses it. It may expose the employee whose value was mostly producing first drafts. Here's how to work with it.

The moves

1/ Send your call with the draft

NEVER send a draft on its own again.

Put 2 lines above it.

The first line is what you recommend, and the second is what would change your mind.

When you send a draft, your boss learns that you did the task.

When you send a recommendation, your boss learns how you think.

Say this

"I recommend option B. It costs more this year, and it removes the risk we raised last quarter. I'd change my mind if the budget gets cut."

2/ Add what the tool can't see

The tool worked from the documents you gave it.

You know which director will push back and what happened the last time the company tried this (you already know who it is).

None of that is in the file.

Write it down in 2 lines under your recommendation.

That context came from years of conversations the tool was never part of.

It is the hardest part of your job to copy, so put it where your boss can read it.

Ask this

Who will object to this, and what will they say?

What did we try before, and why did it stop?

What does this look like 6 months after we say yes?

3/ Spend the saved hours on the decision

The tool gave you back MOST of a day.

Most people spend it producing more drafts (more drafts feel productive, which is the problem).

That's the wrong trade.

Take the next draft to 1 person who will disagree with it before you send it.

More drafts make you faster at the part of the job that just got cheap.

Your boss will remember the 1 call you got right long after the 10 documents you sent.

Do this

Before you send the next draft, show it to 1 person who will disagree with it. Add what they said as a line on top.

The outcome

Most peopleYou
Send the draft and wait for a reactionSend the draft with your recommendation on top
Leave the context in their headWrite down the context the tool never had
Use the saved hours for more draftsUse the saved hours on the decision

Proof. In an experiment with 453 college-educated professionals, access to ChatGPT cut the time spent on writing tasks by 40% and raised output quality by 18%. Noy and Zhang, Science, 2023

This week

The draft used to be the proof that you were working, and now anyone can get it in 40 seconds.

The people who've learned this rule send their judgment FIRST and the draft underneath it.

Try it next time a tool writes something for you.

A draft anyone can produce is a job anyone can do.

Reply

What's the 1 thing you produce every week that a tool could now draft in under a minute? Reply with its name. I read every one.

When you're ready

AI Project Management: run your real projects in 4 weeks while AI handles the busywork. See the course

Management for Hybrid Teams: the operating system for leading people and AI agents on one team. See the course

Project Management That Actually Works: the 7-step system to plan, lead, and finish without winging it. See the course

Until next time.

Justin Bateh, PhD
Former COO, LinkedIn Top Voice
Founder and Editor, Tactical Memo

Sponsor an issue